George Brandis (Queensland, Liberal Party, Minister for the Arts and Sport) Share this | Hansard source

The government does not support Senator Murray’s amendment for the simple reason that it is entirely unnecessary. With due respect, Senator Murray—and in mentioning him for the first time in this debate, I acknowledge his very significant contribution to this discussion over many years—has, I am sorry to say, on this particular occasion done what he so often does: he has raised a straw man only to knock it down. The existing provisions of the act, in particular section 7(3), provide in very clear terms the qualifications requisite to membership of the commission.

I note with interest that neither in Senator Murray’s speech nor in the concurring remarks of Senator Sherry was there any criticism offered or any appointment that this government has ever made to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. So, although sentiments emanating from Senator Murray are characteristically very noble, they also raise a straw man. It is an unnecessary amendment in view of section 7 and also the intergovernmental conduct code agreement, which requires that the Australian government consult with states and territories on proposed appointments to the ACCC. There has never been an issue about the appointment of unsuitable people to the ACCC during the lifetime of this government and nor will there be in the future under the lifetime of this government. Therefore, the government sees no merit in this particular amendment.

Question negatived.