Scott Ryan (President) Share this | Hansard source

Before we move to question time, I'd like to make a short statement following issues that arose yesterday. As senators well know, standing order 193 prohibits the use of offensive words, imputations of improper motives and personal reflections against a member of either chamber. Any such breach is highly disorderly, and an offending senator will be required to withdraw. However, debate in this chamber rests on more than simple rules and standing orders; it is also dependent upon the tone and context of language used by senators. When a senator finds a term offensive, there has often been a request and consent to withdraw a term, although not always and not necessarily with a formal ruling from the chair about it being disorderly. This approach has usually ensured vigorous debate that is at the same time respectful. I would urge all senators to be mindful of all these rules, customs and practices when debating issues in this chamber.

I particularly urge senators to give serious thought to the use of epithets or labels or to ascribing views to other senators when precision of language might more appropriately focus on specific actions or events that are the subject of debate. This is particularly important when dealing with contentious issues and will assist in avoiding crossing the line into disorderly reflections on individuals or imputation of improper motives, including accidentally.