Scott Ryan (President) Share this | Hansard source

First, I didn't hear it, so I can't rule. That is not in the list of terms that I have traditionally ruled out of order, although—

Opposition senators interjecting—

If the opposition could listen to me. I am going to seek some advice from the Clerk about words that we've asked to be withdrawn before, and I will come back to the chamber if necessary, and upon reviewing the Hansard. But I will ask senators to restrain themselves. I'm not certain whether that term has been ruled unparliamentary before, but I will check. I will also urge senators that—

Honourable senators interjecting—

Can I ask senators to listen for a minute. Terms that are parliamentary when used in a general sense are sometimes unparliamentary when specifically directed at a person. That is what I will check about this term. Senator McMahon, can you restart your question, please, because I couldn't hear it.